Workingman wrote:The UK abolished Capital Punishment in 1965, except for a few crimes against the State, such as treason. This was done a decade before we joined the EEC and decades before it evolved into the EU. Leaving the EU will not bring back the death penalty.
When we leave the EU we will still not be able to reinstate the death penalty due to our membership of the ECHR, which has nothing to do with the EU - IT IS A CONVENTION IN ITS OWN RIGHT - and one we would need to withdraw from as a separate issue. Even if we were then not members of both we would still not get the death penalty back because our politicians working in our super Sovereign parliament are overwhelmingly against it, even for terrorism, even if the public wants it - and there is a lot of evidence that we do. Reinstatement in the UK has been tried a number of times and those Bills have always been defeated in both Houses, usually by 2:1.
Just thought you should know.
Now let's be honest about this.
We can't leave the ECHR whilst we are members of the EU
We can't reinstate the death penalty whilst we are signatories to the Treaty of Rome and it's subsidiary treaties.
I didn't say the EU was the reason for our woes. Directly. What I said was that the EU limits our choices on how we DEAL with those woes.
That is a fact and nothing I have said is wrong or incorrect.
As we have seen with Brexit, regardless of what our MP's want, if we vote for a party, in sufficient numbers to break down the status quo, we will be offered choices the MP's do not want to give us. Should we, the people, feel that capital punishment is the only way to resolve some of our issues and should a party rise which offers that and should only 16% of the voters actually vote for that party, then we _will_ get a referendum on capital punishment.
Yes there are a LOT Of IF's in there. But rewind 10 years and put the UK in the situation of UKIP. We were _NEVER_ leaving the EU. It was NEVER going to happen, the people were Never getting a vote and even if we did the government were never going to give us what we voted for.
Never is a very long day and people in politics have had to learn that all over again.
In the EU, no matter what we want and what we vote for we CAN NOT have the option for capital punishment.
This is the point I was talking about. In my world it comes under Direct Brexit Benefits.
Reading the press who don't want to tell us how impossible Brexit is, I see:
Mr Barnier has already admitted that keeping a lid on differences between EU member states over Brexit is “difficult” and warned a brewing row over Britain’s divorce bill is the most likely issue to collapse the talks.
The 66-year-old said: “Checking that what I say - the negotiating lines on the Union side - is agreed by everyone is a lot of work. It is difficult for me and for my co-workers.
“There is a lot of work in consultation and in dialogue with the Council and working groups specialising in Brexit, as well as with the European Parliament and of course here with the college.”
That is what we are leaving. If we want capital punishment we would need to convince 27 countries it's a good thing and that we should modify the treaties, then we'd have to overcome a whole bunch of neo liberal elite, then we'd have to convince ~400 MEP's who are selected by PR by an electorate who think it's not important, then we might, just might be able to have a referendum on it.
In two years time all we need to do is start voting for a party that is single issue on capital punishment.
This is the point I'm highlighting.